[Reblogged from Home Education Forums]
The Scottish Parliament’s Education & Skills Committee is due to reconsider petition PEO1692 for an independent public inquiry into the human rights impact of GIRFEC policy in the coming weeks.
In order to inform the committee’s further deliberations, joint petitioners Alison Preuss (on behalf of the Scottish Home Education Forum) and Lesley Scott (on behalf of Tymes Trust) have sent the following submission in response to the latest correspondence received by the Convener from Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills, John Swinney (dated 22 August 2019) and Dr Ken Macdonald, Head of ICO Regions (8 July 2019): Continue reading “Public inquiry into GIRFEC human rights impact: parliamentary petition update”
Having co-founded the kick-ass children’s rights group ARCH in 2001, I’ve become used to banging on about how the UNCRC resembles a box of Quality Street, where the hardest nuts and caramels are downgraded in favour of the palate-pleasing soft truffles and strawberry cremes.
Article 16 (right to privacy) is one such hard nut that is always left languishing at the bottom of the tin because none of the highly-paid cheerleaders, including the children’s commissioner who has a particular fondness for all things sweet and gooey, wants to risk breaking their molars on it. Continue reading “UNCRC incorporation into Scots law: trick or treat?”
Published in TES Scotland, 29 June 2019
Home-educators ‘face an overtly hostile environment’
Home-educating families are being unfairly treated through Scotland’s health-visiting service, writes Alison Preuss
New research by the Scottish Home Education Forum on families’ experiences of the health-visiting service in Scotland will make uncomfortable reading for service providers and the government alike.
It was prompted by an increase in members’ complaints about the quality and accuracy of information and advice offered by health visitors in relation to childcare, nursery and schooling options, and a lack of transparency regarding the voluntary nature of the service. Continue reading “Home-educators ‘face an overtly hostile environment’”
Earlier this month, Leicestershire Live reported on the case of a parent who was prosecuted and fined for failing to ensure her school-refusing teenage daughter’s regular attendance at school, despite having made valiant efforts to get her there and fully co-operating with the authorities in the face of the child’s outright defiance.
Readers proceeded to express their collective outrage that the mother should have been punished for the actions of the truculent teen, bemoaned (in varying degrees of authoritarian-speak) the breakdown of discipline in ‘schools and society today’, and berated both the council for bringing the action and the magistrates for convicting her. Continue reading “Schooling and the cult of presenteeism”
Published in The Spirit of Inveramsay: ‘Utopia’, R.F. Mackenzie & a tribute to Kenneth Roy (edited by Neil McLellan)
Parallel Lines: my tribute to Kenneth Roy
In October 2010, an email from a senior Scottish politician landed in my inbox asking ‘Did you put Kenneth Roy up to this?’ The ‘this’ was a three-part Scottish Review investigation which had just debunked the government’s flagship GIRFEC (‘Getting It Right For Every Child’) policy as a surveillance scheme in woolly wellbeing clothing.
Read the series: Big Brother Scotland; In the nightmarish world of mass snooping on children, Scotland leads the way; In Scotland’s new world of electronic child surveillance, debased language conceals what is going on
Continue reading “Parallel Lines: my tribute to Kenneth Roy”
In a legal opinion [pdf download] published today, top Manx lawyers have cited the Scottish ‘named person’ judgment handed down by the Supreme Court in 2016 as an authoritative legal precedent that serves to uphold the rights and freedoms of families who choose home education over state schooling.
Following a crowdfunding campaign by concerned parents, Douglas-based Quinn Legal has assessed proposed new legislation by the Isle of Man government as being non-compliant with several articles of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). It also points to likely breaches of the Equality Act when it comes fully into force on the island. Continue reading “Manx home education proposals breach human rights, say lawyers”
The Children’s Commissioner for England, Anne Longfield, seems to believe she knows better than a UN Special Rapporteur on Education. I have previously quoted Katarina Tomasevski on the schooling industry’s hijacking of education which has led to the conflation of self-defined rights with state-dictated outcomes. Like school and education, these are not synonymous and the notion of a rights-respecting school is, frankly, an oxymoron. Continue reading “Dear Children’s Commissioner for England”